A photograph of a missing girl on a milk carton leads Janie on a search for her real identity.

Sixteen-year-old Janie feels devastated when she discovers her boyfriend has betrayed her and her family through his college radio program.

At college in New York City, Janie Johnson, aka Jennie Spring, seems to have successfully left behind her past as "The face on the milk carton," but soon she, her families, and friends are pursued by a true-crime writer who wants their help in telling her kidnapper's tale.